I think it might have worked as a comedy given the cast and screenplay... the original is somewhat of a B-movie and was still better than this dreck...
^ I predict you will quote yourself above, word-for-word, when the rumoured remake of Logan's Run gets released 
No,
Logan's Run can only be remade as a "teen musical" flick
I was a Sand-man but now I'm a run-ner!
We've got a runner! We've got a runner!
They say there's a way out but no one has been there!
We've got a runner! Yeah! We've got a runner!
. . .
Actually I think Hollywood should just pick one movie and remake it over and over to see what the end result of a few thousand bastardizations creates.
Case in point; read H.G. Wells
The Time Machine, then watch the 1960 George Pal version and then watch the Simon Wells version. You will note that the Pal version is based on but diverts from the book in many ways, the Wells version is based on the Pal version but diverts from the film in many ways. I figure if they remake it about 5 or 6 more times it will be a buddy cop movie with two love triangles and a CG hip-hop robot.